Choosing the Right High School

Top 10 Criteria for Choosing the Right High School

Choosing a high school can be a difficult process.  Chesterton Academy of Buffalo is pleased to assist parents by outlining vital benchmarks of successful schools.  We sincerely hope the following criteria will help you as a parent discern the best environment and curriculum for your child.  May God bless your journey and know that we are here to help.

“I want my child to become a saint.”  

(A School Inspired by a Supernatural Vision)

“Take away the supernatural,” says Chesterton, “and what remains is the unnatural.”  The mission of a school, and how it is lived out, should be inspired by the truths of the Catholic faith.  High school students in particular have a predisposition to know the truth.  A school climate should encourage students to ask life’s “big questions” so that students can “discover” the truths of the faith.  A high school that points students on this trajectory in life is a great gift, for there is no higher vision than “the reality of God and of the world to become the measure and standard for one’s own desire and action.”[1]  A student who knows this can live with purpose and change the world.

[1]  Josef Pieper, A Brief Reader on the Virtues of the Human Heart, trans. Paul C. Duggan (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 1988), 20.

“I want my child to find his vocation.”

(A Model that Forms the Whole Person)

“An emphasis on the inalienable dignity of the human person – above all on his or her spiritual dimension – is especially necessary today. Unfortunately, far too many …perceive education to be merely an instrument for the acquisition of information that will improve the chances of worldly success and a more comfortable standard of living. Such an impoverished vision of education is not Catholic.” Education must seek to form children “to fulfilling their destiny to become saints.”[1]  A student’s direction and purpose flow from knowing what we were created for.  An excellent school starts with the view of the student as Capex Dei, or being capable of receiving God.  A school’s view of the human person is to reflect the needs of the student as both body (mind) and soul.  With Christ as the true model, students may be led to develop their intellect and moral virtue to find true fulfillment and joy.  Christ helps us define our purpose and path in life, that is, what we are made for.  As Vatican II states, “…only in the mystery of the incarnate Word, does the mystery of man take on light.”[2]  Students need an environment to discover their unique talents and vocations to be at the service of Christ and his Church.  An excellent school will educate and attend to both the temporal needs that one might fulfill one’s particular vocation and most importantly to provide preparation for one’s eternal end.


[1]Archbishop J. Michael Miller, “Five Essential Marks of Catholic Schools,” Catholic Parents Online.

[2]Vatican II, Gaudium et Spes§22.

“I don’t want my child to fall away from the faith.”

(A Truly Catholic Community)

A school living out its proper mission, provides access to the sacraments for students. In particular the Mass, as the Eucharist is the most effective means of growth in the spiritual life by way of its effects.   It is thesource; the real presence of our Lord, and it is thesummit, the supreme way to holiness (CCC 1377). The school and community rely on the supernatural help from the sacraments in order to live out their mission. Teachers, parents and staff, reflect the living out the sacramental life.  The sacramental life is joyfully embraced and lived out with Mass, prayers, rosary, lives of the saints, and celebratory feasts.  School is a part of a much greater lived experience that merely study. For as G.K. Chesterton said, “Education is not a subject…It is instead a transfer of a way of life.”  When students see the faith as a way of life, and the joy of the ordered life, it becomes much more difficult to leave.

“I want my child to find friends who share our values.”

(Families You Want to Be With)

Friends in high school are one of the most formative influences on a teenager—for good or ill. It is important that parents find a school community where they can trust the other students with whom their son or daughter will spend roughly 8 hours per day with—that’s over 5500 hours in the course of a high school career. As parents know, friends can lead children down a path of happiness or down a path of destruction. Thus parents should also seek a community where they can form meaningful relationships with other parents and families, and where their children can find lifelong friends who will challenge them to live virtuously and encourage them to follow the Lord.

“I want my child to be taught that truth exists.”

(A Curriculum with a Catholic Worldview)

 There is no such thing as a neutral school, every school imparts a worldview. As G.K. Chesterton writes, “every education teaches a philosophy; if not by dogma then by suggestion, by implication, by atmosphere.”  The school must impart the worldview that there is truth, and truth can be known.  There is coherence in the world and in learning.  All truth is God’s truth and therefore cannot be found in just theology but in all subjects.  Faith and reason should be intertwined in every course each student under takes. It is imperative that students find truth in all subjects and that they do not give rise to contradiction.  High school students are quick to recognize and discredit hypocrisy.  In each subject, Catholic values and beliefs are passed on to the students. This integration and consistency give further witness to the truth. As G.K. Chesterton writes, “The one thing that is never taught by any chance in the atmosphere of public schools is this: that there is a whole truth of things, and that in knowing it and speaking it we are happy.”


“I want my child to be surrounded by good role models.”

(A Faculty of Witnesses to the Gospel)

 “Modern man listens more willingly to witnesses than to teachers, and if he does listen to teachers, it is because they are witnesses” (Pope Paul VI).The importance of teacher on a student’s life cannot be overstated.  Research has demonstrated the necessity for children to have other adults in their lives that hold the same values and beliefs as parents. This grows in importance in high school as students seek independence apart from parents. If parents do not trust the teachers to be imitators of Jesus Christ, they cannot trust the school. Additionally, smaller schools provide greater opportunities for individual mentorship and healthy faculty-student relationships.

“I want my child to be a lifelong learner.”

(Students that Seek Wisdom)

Students spend a lot of time in high school immersed in reading and study. The content should thus be worthy and valuable. A high school should supply parents with the main reading list for all the courses for all the high school years. The main course of study should not be teacher-dependent, standardized-test-dependent, or subject to fads, but rather should be the most beneficial for developing habits and fostering wisdom.  Parents shouldn’t accept the low bar of what is “not harmful,” but should demand that students’ minds and hearts receive the best that has ever been thought and said.Parents want the best for their children. Students seeped in the great intellectual tradition become themselves great minds and problem solvers. Parents should seek a school that highlights time-tested and beautiful texts, which students will find both enjoyable and challenging.

“I want my child to be prepared for his future.”

(A Curriculum that Avoids Early Specialization)

 “A dead thing can go with the stream, but only a live thing can go against it.”(G.K. Chesterton). While the trend in education is specialization, a liberal arts curriculum will develop skill sets and appreciation for a wide range of coursework. It is difficult for students to think longer term and discern what is best for them. Students can miss out by not challenging themselves or by not discovering a talent in an area not previously considered. A generalist course of study provides the necessary competencies and avoids the pitfalls of early specialization.  Only 27% of college graduates go into the field in their course of study,[1] and in the workforce, employees often hold several different positions throughout their career. A broad curriculum with few electives in high school leads to greater student knowledge and discernment and therefore to more focus in college and beyond.

[1] Brad Plumer, “Only 27 Percent of College Grads Have a Job Related to Their Major,” The Washington Post, May 20, 2013.

“I want my child to think critically.”

(Coursework with Integrated Connections)

“…The modern academy has literally disintegrated itself into a plethora of fragmented particles, none of which is in communication with the other parts.”[1] High schools that provide content and integration among disciplines will give students the opportunity to synthesize information and develop problem solving skills. Interdisciplinary connections via integrated learningor combined subject coursework, help students develop these creative and higher-level thinking skills. Development and innovation in the world often come from problem solving ability of synthesis of disciplines. Finally, it is a beneficial career skill to appreciate and work with people from different disciplines within an organization.

[1] Joseph Pearce, “Chesterton and the Meaning of Education,” The Imaginative Conservative,February27, 2014.

“I want my child to be able to articulate his ideas.”

(Connected and Engaged Students)

 Seek schools that encourage conversation in the classroom. Interconnectedness with teachers increases not only increases a student’s sense of community, but it leads to greater engagement and satisfaction with school satisfaction.  It’s no secret students learn more when engaged.  Class engagement can happen from a variety of sources but usually it is often a result of teaching methodology.  A critical pedagogy of historical significance, that was forgotten in the 20thcentury is making a comeback, it is the Socratic method.  Questions and class discussion naturally engage students.  The Socratic method engages students, develops the ability to think on one’s feet, and provides practice to share and articulate one’s ideas. Students feel more connected and this yields greater student success.  As stated in an educational study by John Hopkins, “During class, minimize ‘teacher talk’ time and increase ‘student talk’ time…[1] A dialogue is always better than a monologue.

[1]  John Hopkins Urban Health Institute, “Best Practices for Effective Schools,” The Triad of Engagement, 2,

 “I wish they had this when I was a kid”

(A School Parents Wish They Could Attend)

 Upon review of the overall formation and culture of the high school, parents should wish that this education had been made available to them. And if they do, they should make this opportunity available to their child. Parents know best, and they should choose a high school that they think provides the best formation for their child, even if the child is unsure. In most cases, when parents stick with their gut, children end up being grateful to their parents for making the right decision for them.

Your Next Steps

Apply Today

Our Freshman and Transfer Student application process is based on a rolling admissions timeframe. In other words, students may apply to Chesterton Academy at any point throughout the year. However, it is highly recommended that students apply prior to January 20th in order to be eligible for various merit-based scholarships and financial aid awards. Our application may be completed online or downloaded and mailed to the school.

Throughout the application process, our Headmaster or Admissions Director will meet one-on-one with you and your student to develop a customized academic plan, explain the enrollment process and answer any questions you may have. Please click on the button below to apply today.


Enrollment and Re-Enrollment

For every new student enrollment and/or re-enrollment, there is a $250 registration fee. This fee is rolled into the annual tuition cost of $8,075 per student. Our enrollment form and fee may be completed and paid directly online.


TADs Tuition and Financial Aid Registration

Click on the button below to sign-up for a payment schedule or to complete a Financial Aid Application.

TADs Registration

Tuition and Aid

An Affordable Education

Tuition & Fees

Chesterton Academy of Buffalo is committed to offering an outstanding high school education at an affordable cost to families. Tuition for the 2023-24 academic year is $8,075 per student with a $260 book and activity fee. Families with siblings at Chesterton Academy receive a generous tuition discount.

Because tuition does not cover the full cost of an education at Chesterton, families are expected to assist in fundraising and various school activities throughout the school year.

Financial Aid

Scholarships and tuition assistance are available to families who apply and qualify for aid. Chesterton Academy utilizes the services of TADS to help us allocate fairly our limited aid dollars. The student application process must be completed in full before being considered for tuition assistance.

Need Based Scholarships

The following scholarships are available for the 2023-2024 school year for either new freshmen or current students:

  • Russell J Salvatore Scholarship partnered with Chesterton Academy for high-potential students with economic need. Same student may receive up to four years in total.
  • Bison Fund – offered independently through Bison Fund application process.

For more detailed information regarding the aforementioned scholarships and awards, please call the main office at 716/674-8101.

Scholarships and Awards

The following scholarships are available for the 2023-2024 school year:

  • Chesterton Works of Mercy Scholarship – Annual scholarship for one student who has documented an extra-ordinary commitment to Corporal and Spiritual Works of Mercy. This scholarship is not dependent on financial need and may be available for multiple years. Click HERE for application form and details.
  • St. Thomas More Guild of WNY High School and College Scholarship – One $1,500.00 scholarship will be awarded to a student attending a Catholic high school in the Diocese of Buffalo. Click HERE for application information. One $2,000.00 scholarship will be awarded to a student attending either a Catholic college or an ABA accredited law school. The student should be domiciled in the Diocese of Buffalo and be a practicing Catholic.

Incoming freshmen are eligible for the following 2023-2024 scholarships:

  • Chesterton Honors Award – $500 one-time award will be offered to one incoming freshman that achieved high honors status in both 7th and 8th grade (as indicated on official school transcript) as well as submitted a superior essay on why Chesterton Academy of Buffalo is the student’s first choice for high school.
  • St. Thomas More Guild of WNY High School Scholarship – One $1,500.00 scholarship will be awarded to a student attending a Catholic high school in the Diocese of Buffalo. Click HERE for application information.

For more detailed information regarding the aforementioned scholarships and awards, please call the main office at 716/674-8101.

Admissions Events

Frequently Asked Questions

Life at Chesterton

Chesterton works to limit assigned homework to an hour and a half to two hours per evening. We seek to be efficient in the learning process such that students have time in the evenings to spend with their family and extracurricular activities or jobs. We also build into the class schedule free periods throughout the week so students may use this time to study or take a break as needed.

7:55AM Homeroom

8:00AM Mass

8:45AM 1st Period

9:33AM 2nd Period

10:21AM 3rd Period

11:09AM 4th Period

11:57AM 4th Period (Lunch)

12:28PM 5th Lyceum (Free Period)

12:57PM 6th Period

1:45PM 7th Period

2:30PM Dismissal

Students bring their own lunch and may use school microwave to heat meals. Pizza and other lunches are available on various days throughout the week for purchase.

Students are assigned their house and are announced the first day of school. Once a house has been chosen for a student, they will remain in that house until they graduate.

Chesterton welcomes transfer students each year who come from public, private, and homeschool environments. Our Headmaster, Academic Dean and Guidance Team work closely with each transfer student and their family to ensure their success as they transition to Chesterton.

Preparing for Your First Day

Students who live within a 15 mile radius of Chesterton may receive busing according to their home public school district. Applications for transportation are required each year and are approved by the student’s home public school district. Students outside the 15 mile radius are responsible for their own transportation.  Many families form carpools to share transportation.  Please ask the main office for more details.

The tradition of school uniforms goes back to Medieval times when cap and gowns were required at universities. Thus, all students regardless of background would dress alike and all would show an outward sign of their dedication to that university. Our school uniform policy supports three goals: modesty, professionalism and unity/school spirit.

Chesterton students are required to read one classical work over the summer each year.

The school supply list is released in July together with details on the summer reading assignments and uniform policy.